Long Hose vs Standard Octopus: Which Regulator Setup Should You Dive?

By Ibel Perez, owner of Super Diver 911

Every diver who buys their own regulator faces this choice. Run the setup you learned on — a primary regulator for you, and a bright backup (the octopus) for your buddy? Or run a long hose, breathe from it yourself, and hand that regulator to a buddy who needs air?

Both setups are safe. Both are taught. They just share air in two different ways.



First, the Words — Explained Simply





  • Second stage: the part of the regulator that goes in your mouth and gives you air when you inhale.

    • Octopus (or octo): a spare second stage, carried only as a backup. Divers also call it an alternate air source — a second way to get air.

    • Donate: to give a regulator to a buddy who is out of air, so they can breathe from your tank.

    • Primary donate: a way of sharing air where you give your buddy the regulator in your own mouth, then switch to your backup.

    • Long hose: a primary second stage on a much longer hose than standard — usually 5 or 7 feet — set up for primary donate.

  • Every diver must carry a backup second stage. That rule does not change. What changes is which regulator your buddy gets, and how much hose comes with it.

Setup 1: The Standard Octopus



This is the setup almost every diver learns in their first course, and the one most rental gear uses.

  • Your primary second stage sits on a hose about 28 to 29 inches long.

  • Your octopus sits on a slightly longer hose, about 36 to 40 inches, and is often yellow so a buddy can spot it fast.

  • The octopus clips to the front of your BCD (your buoyancy vest), in the open space between your chin and the bottom of your ribs — the golden triangle. Your buddy looks at your chest, sees the yellow regulator, and takes it.



How sharing air works: your buddy signals “out of air,” takes your octopus, and you both hold on to each other and go up together, slow and controlled. That is the drill NAUI and PADI teach from the very first course, and it works.

The strong points:

  • Everyone knows it. Almost every diver on the boat was trained this way. In a stressful moment, familiar is a real advantage.

  • Simple and cheap to set up. It is the standard build on most regulator packages.

  • Your primary never leaves your mouth. You keep breathing from the regulator you were already using.





The weak points:

  • You stay very close. A 36-to-40-inch hose means two divers face to face, nearly chest to chest, for the whole swim up. Workable in open water — a real problem in a tight space, like inside a wreck.

  • Octopuses come loose. A clipped octopus can pop free and drag along the bottom, picking up sand and damage.

  • A panicked buddy may not take it. A diver out of air often reaches for the regulator they know works — the one in your mouth. Then you are the one who has to find the octopus, fast.



Setup 2: The Long Hose (Primary Donate)



This setup came from cave and wreck diving, where two divers may need to swim in a line, one behind the other, while sharing one tank. In the last few years it has moved into everyday recreational diving, as more divers copy the cleaner setups used by technical divers.

  • Your primary second stage sits on a hose 5 or 7 feet long. A 5-foot hose is the common recreational choice. A 7-foot hose is the technical standard, made for single-file swims.

  • The hose runs down your back, under your arm, across your chest, and around the back of your neck to your mouth. Routed right, it lies flat and neat against your body.

  • Your backup second stage hangs on a short hose, about 22 to 24 inches, on a stretchy cord around your neck, right under your chin. You can find it without looking.



How sharing air works: your buddy signals “out of air.” You hand them the regulator from your own mouth — the one you were just breathing, so you know it works — and the long hose gives them room to move. You reach under your chin and put your backup in your mouth. Then you both go up together, with space to swim.

The strong points:

  • Your buddy gets a regulator that is proven to work — you were breathing from it one second earlier.

  • Room to move. Five to seven feet of hose lets two divers swim in a line, turn, and help each other without pulling the regulator out of anyone’s mouth.

  • Nothing dangles. The backup sits tight under your chin, and the long hose lies flat. No trailing octopus dragging on the reef.





The weak points:

  • It is a different drill, and it must be practiced. Primary donate is not the skill most divers learned in their first course. Handing over the regulator in your mouth feels strange the first few times — so practice it on land and in the shallows with your buddy, not for the first time in a real emergency.

  • The hose must be routed right. A long hose stuffed anywhere it fits can trap itself under other gear and fail to come free when your buddy pulls it. The routing is part of the system.

  • Travel friction. With new buddies, expect to explain your setup during the pre-dive check. It takes one minute, and good divers do it anyway.



Does a Long Hose Change How the Regulator Breathes?



Short answer: not in a way you can feel. The air in the hose sits at pressure, ready to go. When you inhale, the first stage (the part on your tank) tops it back up at once. In the water, with a modern first stage, divers do not feel the difference — even breathing hard. Hose length is a sharing decision, not a breathing decision.

Shopping for the gear in this guide?

See the exact gear this post talks about in our shop — family-owned, free U.S. shipping, and we match and beat any authorized dealer's discount.

👉 Shop the gear at superdiver911.com

So Which One Should You Dive?




  • New diver, or diving mostly on vacation with rental-style setups and new buddies? Stay with the standard octopus. It is the setup everyone around you knows, and knowing it cold beats any small gain.

  • Buying your own full regulator set and diving with the same buddy or team? Either setup can be right — but this is the moment a long hose is easiest to adopt, because you will learn it from day one with your own gear.

  • Drawn to wrecks, or thinking about technical training later? Learn the long hose, with an instructor, and practice it until donating is boring. It is the standard path in that world.

  • Worried about a panicked grab? Primary donate answers that directly: the regulator a panicked buddy grabs is the one they are meant to get.




One rule matters more than the whole comparison: dive the setup you and your buddy have agreed on and practiced. Talk it through in your pre-dive check, every time.

How This Works at Super Diver 911




Hose length is a choice you make when we build your setup. The NEX LP Regulator Hose is custom-made: rubber or braided, in your color, from $57.89. Listed lengths run from 22 to 32 inches — the sizes used for a backup on a necklace and for a primary hose. Need a longer hose for an octopus or a full long-hose build? Those are cut to order: tell us the length and we build it for your setup.

Want a hose built to your exact length? See how our custom hoses are made

Putting a whole regulator together? Start with the full line on our shop page, tell us which setup you want to dive, and we will build it that way and confirm every detail before it ships.







Quick Questions, Straight Answers




How long is a standard octopus hose?

About 36 to 40 inches — longer than the primary hose (about 28 to 29 inches), so a buddy has a little room. A long hose, by comparison, is 5 or 7 feet.

Can a recreational diver use a long hose?

Yes. Nothing in the rules limits it to technical divers. The catch is training: learn the donating drill with a buddy or an instructor and practice it in calm water before you rely on it.

Which regulator do I give — mine or the octopus?

It depends on your setup. Standard: your buddy takes your octopus. Long hose: your buddy takes your primary, and you switch to the backup under your chin. What matters is that your buddy knows which one before the dive.

Do both divers in a pair need the same setup?

No — but each of you needs to know how the other’s gear gives air. One minute of talking during the gear check covers it.













The Bottom Line




The standard octopus is simple, familiar, and taught everywhere — a fine choice for most divers. The long hose gives a buddy a proven regulator and room to swim, at the cost of learning a new drill. Pick the one that matches your diving, practice how it shares air, and make sure your buddy is in on the plan.

Want to keep learning? Read our guide to how to choose a scuba regulator for the full picture, and our guide to the most common scuba emergencies for how air sharing fits into the bigger safety picture.

Not ready to buy yet? Join free for gear tips and the monthly special: superdiver911.com/membership

Ready to build your setup? Browse the regulators and custom hoses at superdiver911.com — gear ships free anywhere in the U.S. except P.O. boxes and military APO/FPO/DPO addresses. Not sure which setup fits the diving you do? Reach out — you’ll get a straight answer from a diver, not a call center.

Support the little guy — shop with a family-owned dive shop.


Super Diver 911 is a small, family-owned dive shop. When you buy from us instead of a big-box store, you keep real dive shops alive — the shops that train divers, service gear, and keep this sport personal. Visit our website, browse the gear, and reach out any time: we match and beat any authorized dealer's discount, and shipping is free anywhere in the U.S.


👉 Shop at superdiver911.com





Let’s help the little guy — support the family-owned dive shops. They’re the heart of this sport.

Ibel Perez

🌊 Premium Dive Gear at superdiver911.com

https://www.superdiver911.com
Previous
Previous

Thinking About Scuba School but a Little Scared? What It’s Really Like — and How Safe It Is

Next
Next

Dive Shop or Online Store? An Honest Guide to Where to Buy Your Scuba Gear